The 3 Protein Archetypes: A Blueprint From Human History
For thousands of years, humans have thrived on radically different diets. But zoom out, and nearly all traditional cultures fall into three protein archetypes — shaped by climate, food availability, and biology. Here’s what modern science can teach you.
1. The Plant-Protein Optimizers
Ancestral Pattern: In regions like rural India, Ethiopia, and Southeast Asia, traditional diets were built on lentils, chickpeas, fermented grains, seeds, and tubers — with little to no meat. The gut microbiome, shaped by constant exposure to fiber and phytochemicals, became incredibly efficient at extracting protein and nutrients from plants.
Science: Some research shows that with good nutrient planning (B12, iron, lysine), vegetarian diets can support long-term healthy living in some people. Genetics and gut flora may play a major role in determining who thrives most on these diets.
2. The Balanced Omnivores
Ancestral Pattern: Most agrarian societies — from the Mediterranean to East Asia — ate diets rich in whole grains, legumes, seasonal vegetables, and modest animal protein. These cultures show a balance between animal and plant protein sources, often with strong traditions of fermentation and slow cooking.
Science: The Blue Zones, home to the world’s longest-lived people, are mostly omnivorous. Diets from places like Okinawa and Sardinia include legumes, fish, and plant diversity. Studies link these diets to lower rates of heart disease, diabetes, and dementia.
Note: The Mediterranean diet continues to rank #1 in clinical research for cardiovascular and metabolic health. NB: It’s not just about what’s eaten, but how — slow meals, seasonal variety and who prepares the food is very important.
3. The Carnivore Thrivers
Ancestral Pattern: Arctic Inuit, Maasai, and Plains tribes lived on diets with 60–90% animal protein and fat — often with no plant foods at all. Over generations, they developed metabolic adaptations that allowed them to thrive without carbohydrates. The Inuit, for example, carry a variant of the CPT1A gene, which enhances fat metabolism in cold, high-fat environments.
Science: Today, carnivore diets — built around red meat, organ meats, and zero carbs — are showing remarkable results in individuals with autoimmune disorders, gut dysfunction, or insulin resistance. Though controversial, emerging research and suggests that for some, this ancestral pattern still fits.
What’s Best for You?
The debate over “the best” diet misses the deeper truth: there is no universal ideal. Your body is the result of thousands of years of ancestral adaptation and your optimal protein source may be written into your DNA, microbiome, and ancestral heritage. Instead of following a trend, we should be asking: what did my lineage evolve to digest, absorb, and thrive on?
Think Well!
HR
If you would like guidance on your personal nutritional profile please book a free discovery session here.
Hayden Rhodes Coaching 